MCDONNELL DOUGLAS AIRCRAFT CO MD 88Delta Air Lines
648 lines · 09:00:47.4 – 11:02:53.5 · New York, NY, 2015-03-05
- 11:02:33.1CAWS[sound of CAWS landing gear configuration warning horn lasts until end of recording]
- 11:02:40.4CAM-?(idle or out of) reverse. (idle or out of) reverse.
- 11:02:43.2CAM[sound of louder scraping lasting 8.3 seconds]
- 11:02:45.1LGADelta ten eighty six? DCA15FA085 Time and Time and Source Source
- 11:02:47.6CAM-?#.
- 11:02:48.0CAM-?#.
- 11:02:49.4CAM-?#.
- 11:02:51.6CAM[sound of scraping noise ends]
- 11:02:51.8LGADelta ten eighty six?
- 11:02:53.5CAM-?#.
Crew communication
648 lines readobservations a human-factors reviewer takes from a transcript — the sterile cockpit, the Board's own notations, rhythm, CRM markers. Not emotions, not scores: the affect is in the audio, and the audio is sealedWindow: 23:39:36–23:41:44 · basis: recorder pressure altitude below 10,000 ft. Candidate non-pertinent lines below are a first reading for the investigator, not a finding; “@” marks the Board's own non-pertinent-word notation.
No candidate non-pertinent conversation inside the window.
Delivery and physiological notes the transcribers added in brackets, plus # expletives. 54 words are marked unintelligible (*).
- #10:08:33.5“I hope people are re— reporting it yeah. cause that's typical Microsoft. it gets buggier the more you up— you download # on it you know.”
- #10:13:37.8“he's hanging his— he's hanging his # out if he uses the max manual. DCA15FA085 Time and Time and Source Source”
- #10:14:05.3“and they say use max autobrake then transition then max manual braking. #.”
- #10:14:19.8“I like this one. touchdown speed is v ref forty minus five. so unless you catch that one everyone's already bugging five. you know? now you gotta slow your # down man. this is— this is you got to slow down before you even touch down.”
- #10:17:19.8“oh #. the rest of the story is we took off from Atlanta to LaGuardia and uh we ended up holding for forever. every”
- #10:19:52.2“# you're no fun.”
- sound similar to cockpit door closing10:21:13.3“[sound similar to cockpit door closing]”
- sound similar to cockpit door closing10:24:21.4“[sound similar to cockpit door closing]”
- #10:26:33.4“you gotta be # me.”
- automated voice10:26:35.4“[sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert]”
- automated voice10:26:39.9“[sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice]”
- automated voice10:26:39.9“[sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice]”
- automated voice10:26:39.9“[sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice]”
- #10:26:56.8“come on you #.”
- #10:27:25.5“nice heads up from the dispatcher. the #. DCA15FA085 Time and Time and Source Source”
- sound similar to sigh10:37:19.0“[sound similar to sigh]”
- #10:53:04.4“you #.”
- #10:56:16.4“yeah she's # crazy.”
- automated voice11:01:02.6“one thousand. [automated voice]”
- automated voice11:01:39.3“five hundred. [automated voice] DCA15FA085 Time and Time and Source Source”
- automated voice11:02:08.7“one hundred. [automated voice]”
- automated voice11:02:11.6“fifty. [automated voice]”
- automated voice11:02:12.6“forty. [automated voice]”
- automated voice11:02:13.2“thirty. [automated voice] DCA15FA085 Time and Time and Source Source”
- +6 more
- 3244 s09:00:47.4 → 09:54:51.8
- 385 s09:58:59.6 → 10:05:24.1
- 91 s10:17:19.8 → 10:18:50.3
- 81 s10:48:46.5 → 10:50:07.2
- 80 s10:43:40.1 → 10:44:59.7
- 65 s09:57:50.7 → 09:58:56.1
- 64 s10:16:13.8 → 10:17:18.2
- 62 s10:35:57.9 → 10:36:59.9
Hedged or questioning lines from one pilot in the critical window, with the other pilot’s next words.
None found in the window.
- 10:26:15.8[sound similar to altitude alert]→ 2.9 s later: 10:26:18.7“we got plenty of time.”
- 10:26:35.4[sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert]→ no crew words within 5 s
- 10:26:39.9[sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice] [sound similar to altitude alert] altitude. [automated voice]→ no crew words within 5 s
- 10:42:12.0[sound similar to altitude alert]→ no crew words within 5 s
- 10:50:39.0[sound similar to altitude alert]→ no crew words within 5 s
- 10:53:38.4[sound similar to altitude alert]→ no crew words within 5 s
- 11:02:17.9[sound of beep] [CAWS configuration warning]→ 0.6 s later: 11:02:18.5“spoilers up.”
- 11:02:18.3[sound of beep] [CAWS configuration warning]→ 0.2 s later: 11:02:18.5“spoilers up.”
- 11:02:18.9speedbrakes.[automated voice. CAWS configuration warning]→ 2 s later: 11:02:20.9“two in reverse.”
- 11:02:33.1[sound of CAWS landing gear configuration warning horn lasts until end of recording]→ no crew words within 5 s
- 10:14:34.2“and— and you are going to ILS minimums. so how much runway do we actually have available?”
- 10:21:28.4“but why?”
- 10:22:49.1“wouldn't that be lovely?”
- 10:28:57.9“said it seems like everybody else is sort of surprised by this. you know we knew the weather was— this is New York. I mean what do you think happens here?”
- 10:31:16.9“okay we're going to two zero zero. it's IAS. it's descending. it's armed...uh our alternate is Albany. Albany right?”
- 10:32:34.8“so that's nine thousand from over uh...there. the burn from Robbinsville to uh LaGuardia is what?”
- 10:42:07.5“what?”
- 10:46:30.8“uh of baro DA of uh two fourteen is crosschecked. landing data?”
- 10:52:06.0“where is everybody?”
- 10:56:17.9“can you hear me now?”
“Not in transcript” never means “not said”: a line may be unintelligible, or the recording may not cover that phase.
| Speaker | words | questions | hedges | exclamations | expletives | checklists | non-pertinent lines |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Captain | 2,106 | 28 | 19 | 8 | 8 | 0 | 34 |
| First officer | 2,581 | 27 | 11 | 6 | 6 | 0 | 33 |
| Observer / jumpseat | 309 | 11 | 5 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 12 |
Read next to the Board’s coded human-factors findings on the case page. The NTSB cautions that a transcript is not a precise science; these are pointers into it, for a trained reader to weigh.
Hover a line to bookmark it or write a note against it — the note keeps the line’s time, speaker and words.